Armenia and Azerbaijan: The Waltz of (Missed) Meetings

Armenia and Azerbaijan: The Waltz of (Missed) Meetings

© LukeOnTheRoad7Shutterstock

A trilateral meeting between Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia should take place tomorrow, November 26, in the Russian tourist resort of Sochi. At the center of the diplomatic initiative the possible agreements between the two warring countries. However, the information is still scarce.

The hopes for a possible meeting on 9-10 November between Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, and Russia’s Vladimir Putin soon fell flat. Furthermore, new clashes occurred on the Armenia-Azerbaijan border. It was the worst flare-up since the 2020 ceasefire agreement.

 

Armenia and Azerbaijan accused each other for the fighting that left at least six Armenian and seven Azerbaijani soldiers dead. Around two dozen Armenian soldiers are also believed to have been taken prisoner by Azerbaijan. This, adding to existing concerns regarding those already held by Baku since late last year, dashed any hopes for a breakthrough.

 

That is, until now.

 

As suggested by Radio Free Europe in mid-October, the European Union was preparing a meeting between Aliyev and Pashinyan on the sidelines of the EU Partnership Summit scheduled for Brussels next month. That was confirmed on 19 November by Charles Michel, the European Council’s president. Russia, not wanting to have its own role diminished, surfaced again as possible facilitator of a meeting, also confirmed for 26 November in the Russian seaside resort of Sochi.

 

[…]

 

It remains unclear whether any such a document might be signed at the end of this week, but the timing of the press conference gives reason to think that it could be on the cards. Regardless, argues Giragosian, some obstacles and issues remain unresolved.

 

“Given the delay in the return of all prisoners of war and civilian non-combatant detainees from Azerbaijani captivity, the required return to diplomacy only furthers the delay in reaching a negotiated peace agreement”, he says. “In this context, the timetable for such a peace agreement lies largely with the Azerbaijani government and will depend on when Baku is ready to re-engage in the peace process”.

 

As of writing, hopes that a breakthrough might be forthcoming at the Sochi meeting appeared to be bolstered by last-minute shuttle diplomacy. A day after Pashinyan’s televised interview, Russian Deputy Prime Minister Alexei Overchuk visited both Baku and Yerevan.

The full article is here.

One Year After the 2020 Karabakh War

One Year After the 2020 Karabakh War

Emreculha / wikimedia CC

Though the future remains unpredictable, last year’s war between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the disputed territory of Nagorno Karabakh changed the geographical and geopolitical landscape in the South Caucasus after three decades of bitterness, conflict, and division. Now, some analysts hope, there is an opportunity to turn a new page in Armenia-Azerbaijan relations.

The 9-10 November 2020 ceasefire that ended last year’s fighting should have clarified this future, but a lack of transparency and a drought of objective or informed analysis has left the public in both countries confused and in the dark. Certainly, some provisions of the agreement remain unfulfilled, though that might change in the coming weeks and months.

 

Armenia wants Azerbaijan to return the remaining captives that it holds while Baku is frustrated that an anticipated transport link running through Armenia to its exclave of Nakhichevan, as dictated by the ceasefire agreement, has not yet been established. It also demands that Yerevan hand over any maps of minefields in territory now back under Baku’s control.

 

Meanwhile, despite more frequent talk of normalising relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan, and possibly Armenia and Turkey too, there have been no clear signs as to when such developments might happen.

 

“For 12 months, the Armenian government and much of the population has been limited to a state of denial where it took many, many months in order to accept a new reality,” says Richard Giragosian, the director of the Regional Studies Center (RSC) in Yerevan. Now, he says, those signs might be on the horizon.

 

“The turning point,” he says, “came on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly in New York [in September] when the Armenian and Azerbaijani Foreign Ministers with the OSCE Minsk Group mediators were able to reconvene in a meeting that heralds the return and resumption of diplomacy over the force of arms.”

 

“This marks a return to diplomacy and a belated Armenian adjustment to a painful, unprecedented new reality.”

The full article is here.

Archive: Yerevan’s Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable

Archive: Yerevan’s Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable

Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable,
Yerevan, Armenia © Onnik James Krikorian 2002

I’ve covered too many subject matters and issues in over two decades of being based in the South Caucasus to upload everything to my new website so a few photographs taken at Yerevan’s Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable taken in 2002 as a quick blog post. It was part of a much larger multi-year personal project to raise awareness of poverty and social vulnerability in Armenia.

In general, or at least throughout the 2000s, it was rare to come across someone blind unless they were begging on the streets. However, the kids at the boarding school were amazing and very talented so I went back many times and got to them very well. 

Armine, Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable,
Yerevan, Armenia © Onnik James Krikorian 2002

Sadly, I can’t find any of the articles I wrote on the boarding school, but just to say that while it was mainly intended for children who were blind or visually impaired, fully sighted kids from impoverished families where one or both of the parents were blind were also enrolled. Moreover, despite much controversy surrounding the Soviet-era boarding schools operating in Armenia, this one was run properly as was another catering for death or hearing impaired kids.

Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable,
Yerevan, Armenia © Onnik James Krikorian 2002

Since shooting much of this material, it’s been interesting to discover that many of the children went on to higher education. One blind girl, Armine (pictured in the second photograph on this post), went to study a Masters in the United Kingdom, while on blind boy, Artak Beglaryan, is better known to many as the former Human Rights Ombudsperson in Nagorno Karabakh. Beglaryan was blinded by a landmine explosion in Karabakh as a kid and is now a senior official there.

Artak Beglaryan, Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable, Yerevan, Armenia © Onnik James Krikorian 2002

Anyway, some more photographs in the galleries below: 

Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable,
Yerevan, Armenia © Onnik James Krikorian 2002

Boarding School for the Blind, Visually Impaired, and Socially Vulnerable,
Yerevan, Armenia © Onnik James Krikorian 2002

Remembering Georgi Vanyan

Remembering Georgi Vanyan

Georgi Vanyan © Meydan TV

Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso has just published my short piece remembering Armenian human rights and peace activist Georgi Vanyan who sadly passed away recently after testing positive for COVID-19 earlier this month. 

The last time I spoke to Georgi Vanyan was by telephone at the end of September. The Armenian human rights and peace activist was visiting Tbilisi […] and there were now plans to visit the Georgian village where many of his previous activities were held.

 

Georgi invited me accompany them, but there was one problem.

 

The 58-year-old was feeling ill and needed to test for COVID-19 before we could meet. Two days later, he sent a text message to say that he had tested positive and had to self-isolate in Tbilisi. He’d be in touch once he had recovered, but things took a turn for the worse and he was hospitalised. Eventually moved on to a ventilator, Georgi Vanyan was pronounced dead on 15 October.

 

The loss was a personal tragedy for those that knew him and also for a handful of committed individuals that had been working across closed borders in pursuit of regional peace.

 

“Now, at this stage of the Armenian-Azerbaijani reconciliation process, the peacebuilding community needed him more than ever,” tweeted Baku-based regional analyst and researcher Ahmad Alili. “Sincere Person. Genuine Peacebuilder. Great Loss. Rest in Peace, Georgi.”

The full article can be read here.

An immeasurable and catastrophic loss for the region – Georgi Vanyan RIP

An immeasurable and catastrophic loss for the region – Georgi Vanyan RIP

Georgi Vanyan, Tekali, Georgia © Onnik James Krikorian 2012

It is with great sadness that I write this post. Georgi Vanyan, human rights and peace activist, has died. Upon hearing that he had been moved on to a ventilator after being diagnosed and hospitalised in Tbilisi with COVID-19 I think we knew that this was how it was going to end, but that doesn’t make the loss any less painful. Following last year’s war, Georgi was needed now more than ever.

Arguably the most genuine peace builder in the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict, Georgi was admittedly a controversial figure at home. In 2007 he held a Days of Azerbaijan cultural event at an experimental Yerevan school that was interrupted by nationalist bloggers and many who received grants for peacebuilding, perhaps feeling threatened by someone more genuine than they were, cynically attempted to ostracise him as well. Armenian mass media also launched a coordinated campaign to discredit his work.

In 2009, therefore, I had to meet him. I also had to interview him.

[…] Vanyan argues […]  there needs to be new approaches taken to prepare society for peace. Indeed, he says, the desire to end the conflict needs to be there in the first place.  “Armenians and Azerbaijanis are human beings first of all and have a basic desire for peace. What we need to do is to make this basic desire public and to initiate some kind of open public discussion. Instead of organizing seminars and talking to NGOs, we talk to people in the markets, or in local cultural centers.”

Perhaps Georgi’s greatest legacy will be his Tekali Process, the regular gathering of activists, academics, and residents of Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Georgia in the small ethnic Azerbaijani village of Tekali located close to where the borders of all three countries intersect. I traveled with Georgi at the end of January 2011 to review the potential location for the first meeting held in March the same year. 

The roads have seen better days and probably so too have the villagers, but if events continue to be held in a small ethnic Azeri village in Georgia that might all change. Situated just 10 kilometers from the Georgian border with Azerbaijan, and 29 kilometers from the crossing with Armenia, those attempting to establish Tekali as a regional peacebuilding center certainly hope so. One of them, Armenian theatrical director turned activist Georgi Vanyan has already called on other NGOs to relocate some of their existing and future regional and cross-border projects there. If that were to happen, much needed investment could be attracted to Tekali as well as the surrounding area and involve wider society in dialogue, discussion and debate.

Sadly, I could not rejoin Georgi for another visit to Tekali at the beginning of this month, over 10 years later. He had rung me up saying that he might have COVID-19 and so didn’t want to put me in harms way. Once his situation was clear, he said, he will take me there again. Two days later, this was our last communication via FB messenger.

Georgi, you are already missed.

With Armenia and Azerbaijan seemingly close to normalising relations after three decades of animosity there are many of us so sorry that you are now no longer here to see it. You will always be in our memories, however, and despite the efforts of all those who ganged up against you, we will make sure that you are never forgotten.

Georgi, you are a tremendous inspiration and will forever remain so.

Rest in Peace.